OK, so let's hear some honesty from the blogmunity. Is there anyone in this Top Ten who would compel you to part with your hard earned $$ for a summer tour ticket?
I'm seriously not feelin' the love.
Season Ruben - Clay? Been there, saw the panties flying. There was excitement, endearment, hordes of people who loved that season, those two in particular.
Season Fantasia? Of course. That was the season that gave us Jennifer Hudson (simultaneously confirming America's head was firmly up its ass by voting her off before Jasmine Trias.)
Season 4 birthed Carrie Underwood and Bo Bice. Well worth the price of a ticket.
Season Daughtry? Forget McPhee and Taylor Hicks (and I was firmly in the Soul Patrol) - Chris Daughtry was, and is, amazing.
Season 6 was just not exciting to me - between Jordin Sparks and splatterpuss Blake Lewis? It never even dawned on me to investigate tickets.
Then there was David Cook. 'Nuff said.
And last season, Adam Lambert exploded into America's living rooms. He didn't win, but he lit up the stage in a way no former contestant ever had. If ever a kid didn't need the win, it was Adam.
Which brings us to Season 9. Yawn. Snoozzzzzzze. We have ten contestants, sure. But most are filler. Appetizers. The Aarons, Tims, Katies, and Didis are the bowl of stale rolls on the table while you wait for your exciting entree of Siobhan Scalloppini and Crystal Cordon Bleu. Sorry, but not even Casey James is doing it for me. He's like a souffle, puffed up, tasty, but ultimately just (h)air.
Maybe Usher can whip a little life into this group. Let's find out...
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Oooo! We get to go backstage! Behind the green curtain in Oz! And what's back there? Plywood, wires, two lines of kids decked out in JEANS and sequins! And a gaggle of judges! (Would that be jaggle of judges?)
Ryan: The next 2 hours mean the world to 10 people (because the past two months they were just passing time?). This spot backstage is the final chance they have to collect themselves (apply mascara, text message, pee). You can literally hear a pin drop (because if you are noisy, Debbie the Stage Manager will beat you to death with Matilda).
(Move forward to jaggle of judges where Ellen and Simon seem to be sweet on one another.)
This is where the action happens (obviously. Look out Simon, Portia could kick your arse.).
Once the contestants cross this line (hopefully having chosen wisely - song, not chalice - name that movie) and walk through these doors, the atmosphere changes.
Cue screaming throng.
T. I. their moment. T. I. your show (No, MY show would be an hour long and not have any commercials). T.I.A.I.
Out came the judges - Randy in his argyle cardigan, Ellen looking like a busboy after a working back-to-back banquets at the Doubletree in an untied bow tie and a grey jacket with cheap piping on the lapels; Kara wore leather pants and a one shouldered smock from Liberace's Dental School; and Simon looked very Jesus Christ Superstar in his drapey white tunic over JEANS.
After welcoming the Idols onto the stage, Ryan then rolled tape on the night's guest mentor - Usher would be on hand to critique them through their Soul / R&B choices.
I love Usher. I love him even more after having watched the kids suffer through a lightweight like Miley Cyrus. Sorry, I do not care that the Disney machine spit her out, or how many CDs she has sold to their Hannah devotees, Miley Cyrus is not yet suited to mentor on this show.
Usher, on the other hand, is pretty amazing. From albums sold, to 3 Grammys, to being a mainstay in the genre he is on hand to assist them with? Spot on choice by the producers. (I am also a lover of Yeah - the song backing the video, and the tune most remembered in The Hangover.)
Besides, the guy has the most adorable kid in the world...
(The muscles aren't bad either... ahem.)
In the studio, Ryan donned shades (more Secret Service than cool, Ryan) chatted up Usher (I'm assuming the guy who stood up next to him was entourage/bodyguard? FAIL.) about the contestants, his new album - Raymond vs Raymond (he threw in the big word 'dichotomy' - hmmmm, brawn AND brains?), and then rolled tape...
Up first, longtime Usher fan, Siobhan, who admitted to being "wicked nervous" upon meeting him. Usher commented on her "unique vocal ability" and then cautioned her to scale back her wardrobe: "don't have so much going on."
Sound advice as she had shown up to see him with her hair a rat's condo (bigger than a nest), her quirky glasses, a t-shirt, vest, chains, bracelets, tights that looked like her legs had been dipped in an oil slick, and Siobhodd footwear - something high and indeterminate.
On stage to sing Through The Fire, she still kept her personality with footwear for wrestling on the moon, but refined her hair - slicked back and braided across the front (the girl IS beautiful). She wore what appeared to be toilet paper, or a hastily grabbed table cloth around her waist, and some black/burgundy fabric wrapped around her torso with one length of toilet paper from the skirt up over her shoulder.
As for the song? Yikes. I have four cats. They could have taken the place of the backup singers on stage with Siobhan. She was sharp, shrill, shouty - and the emotion of the Chaka Khan song was drowned out as it became very obvious everything had once again been engineered around allowing her to scream (a tad more delicately) at the end.
No matter. All four judges hated it, but love her, so all critiques were excuses.
Randy and his elephant (what the hell, dude? You dress like a preschooler on his first day of school) said it was "all over the place" but he loved her "courageousness and conviction"; Ellen said it was like "hiking and you miss the trail" but no matter, "I love you."; Kara called it an "off night", but hey, "you deserve one" (remember that when Andrew slaughters another deer on stage, Kara); Simon was actually honest - "by far your weakest performance and I'm getting bored of the screaming at the end."
What followed were two more minutes of critiquing that left Siobhan looking like she wanted to do nothing more than scream some more - AT THE JUDGES.
Casey worked with Usher next on Hold On I'm Coming. Usher called it a "perfect song choice" and said of Casey, "I am truly impressed with him."
On stage, flanked by a horns section on one side, a cadre of back-up singers on the other, Casey came out in JEANS (duh), boots (double duh), a red shirt covered by a black shirt, hair pulled back, and his binky guitar in place.
I have to give it to him - Casey bores me overall - yes, even despite the good looks, I need more than eye candy, people - but tonight, he sounded pretty amazing. He was confident, used the guitar to full effect, and seemed to truly enjoy being up there. If nothing else, he definitely perked things up after the Siobhan Smackdown.
Randy said, "This was another hot night for you!"; Ellen said that while Casey is "always good" she felt it was a "little generic .. safe zone for you"; Kara agreed that he is "not showing how much" he can do; Simon called it his "strongest week" so far, said Casey "sounded authentic" and that he was "really, really impressed."
Ryan, never one to let a sexual inference AstroGlide by, clarified for Casey that when Kara urged him to "show it all," she meant "musically."
Big Mike worked with Usher next on Ready For Love. He cautioned Mike to be mindful of the audience, to "let everyone feel your energy."
Set up on the small stage behind the judges, Mike was accompanied by Matilda and Bar. He wore JEANS and an entire steer (come on - you know damn well it takes an entire cow to outfit that man in a leather jacket), along with his guitar.
Wow - this song - slow, stripped down - showcased his range, his control, his emotion. Now, if the guy could only sing while awake. Mike - you have to OPEN YOUR EYES.
Randy said Mike is "in the zone"; Ellen called it "beautiful"; Kara said he did "an incredible job"; and Simon said that "for the first time in these live performances, I can actually take you seriously as an artist ... terrific job."
Didi met Usher and did what Didi always does - she cried. Good, bad, happy, sad - Didi cries. For his part, Usher called her song choice of What Becomes Of The Broken Hearted "a very emotional song for a very emotional young lady."
Cut to center stage, Didi draped in a strapless gold and black sequined gown, slit uptothere, her hair wavy and long. She looked beautiful, but continued her career as the spokesmodel for Hooked On Phonics. (Or as Brian Regan says, "Hooo-ked On Pa-honics wor-ked for MEH!"
She's just not good at emoting. She sucks the life out of a song by singing like English is her third language. If she truly had an emotional connection to that song, as she told Usher, it was MIA. The whole performance was FLAT - not so much in singing, but in delivery. Seriously, Dominos delivers pizza with more height.
Randy said it "flatlined for me"; Ellen called it "way dramatic"; Kara said, "It's over done, girl ... you've lost your way"; Simon likened it to "swimming in jelly" then called it "so over the top, so old fashioned, so off melody."
Didi, in response to your asking, What Becomes of the Broken Hearted? Um, they sing at the end of the show on Wednesday nights...
Back from a break, Ryan shared the Stools of Stuff The Show with Tim, or Teflon Tim as the press is dubbing him, for his ability to let the judges' comments slide off. (I personally think it's his brain that is shellacked and simply doesn't get it.)
With Usher he practiced Sweet Love - Usher stopped him and asked "have you ever been in love?" He then told Tim to sing to him that way - UGH. Watching Tim sing to Usher (who looked away) was WAY uncomfortable. Tim's maybe been in love with hair gel, a poster of a girl, or a girl across the classroom, but I'm not buying he has any intimate knowledge of, well, intimate knowledge.
On stage, dressed in JEANS, a white dress shirt, loose tie, and blazer, he started singing while sitting on the stairway to Ryan's heaven, and he is Didi's male counterpart in HOP land. Staring straight ahead, he had the look of a stalker - not blinking, just staring - not a passionate dude trying to woo a woman. He appeared to be walking through cement, and what is up with the head constantly tilted to the side? Is his hair that heavy?
Randy said that while he "sang in tune" there was "no vibe, no swag"; Ellen talked about the home version of Tim Urban on Idol in which people drink when she calls him "adorable" then said all she did was wonder "why did you choose THAT song?"; Kara called it "Broadway at times, Vegas at times ... you took the soul out of the song"; Simon summed it up: "You're going to smile, the audience is going to vote for you, nobody cares, you'll be here next week, well done."
Translation: The Hello Kitty crowd is enamored and has no taste what so ever.
Andrew had his turn with Usher to strip down another song, this time Forever. Usher said, "he made me love it even more."
On stage, in a purple checked shirt and shiny gray suit, he sat on Bar with his guitar and JUST SANG. He slowed the song down and did his damndest to Forever make us forget Straight Up. I'd say mission accomplished, Andrew. The vocal was the show this time, and it made me forget the singing / dancing nightmare of last week. (Lesson learned? NEVER ever everever take advice from Hannah Montana.)
Randy hollered, "Andrew is back!"; Ellen called it a "really amazing, strong performance"; Kara said it was "one giant leap in the right direction"; Simon said it was "miles, miles better" but said "as a person you come over as very boring."
This unleashed Mama Garcia, and if Big Mike was wearing an entire bovine, she had skinned an entire zebra. She went up to Simon and a torrent of Spanish came out in defense of her son. I didn't understand, but I know she was not asking about the bathroom or ordering two beers.
Katie was next to re-meet Usher - apparently she had run into him at Epcot once, but big, burly bodyguard dude wouldn't let her get a picture.
She sang Chain of Fools and he encouraged her to show some "pizzazz and attitude." Sorry, Usher. She's had a McPheemapotomoplasty - the removal of all pizzazzitude.
On stage, her hair pulled back into a long ponytail, wearing shiny leggings, gladiator heels, a gray shorts romper, and crystal Hula Hoops in her ears, she attempted to work her way through Chain of Fools, but I wasn't buying. She has a big voice, but she has not lived long enough to be a link in anyone's chain. And the "oh no you di-ent" head wobble? Katie, you are a 17 year old white girl. STOP.
Randy contradicted himself with "a little disconnected vocally" yet "one of the best of the night" and a comparison to Xtina; Ellen commented on the "Snooky poof" hairdo; Kara called "one of your best vocal performances"; but Simon again was realistic, saying it was "pretty good" but "very robotic, quite cold" and like something from "Star Search."
She then bogarted Crystal's answer when Ryan asked who she was going to listen to. "Myself."
Oh no you di-ent. (insert wobble of head)
Lee shared the Chat Chairs to be asked by Ryan, "How do you create a moment." Lee, being the toastmaster he is (not), responded with something along the lines of, "Performing and giving a performance in which you perform performerly. Can't I just sing, dude?"
With Usher he rehearsed Treat Her Like A Lady, which Usher called a "special treat." He told Lee he has "an incredible voice - just own it."
On stage, guitar in hand, dressed in a black shirt, JEANS, and a blazer, Lee finally gave up leasing, renting, co-opting - he did own it. He connected to the song in a way he never has, even smiled a couple times, and seemed to be enjoying himself. Vocally, there is never an issue - he has a natural gift - is gritty without having to try. You and me? We'd have to swallow a beachful of sand to sound like that.
Randy called it "unbelievable" and "the best I've heard you in weeks" Ellen said, "Now the night's started."; Kara called him "amazing"; Simon said he's "always believed" in Lee," but that "This was the night your life may have changed forever."
Lee's response? He stuck his guitar pick in his mouth.
Finally it was time for Crystal to back up her promise of a "big surprise" this week. She played coy with Usher, but he guessed it, "play the piano and sing." Bingo!
Usher loved her, but then, what's not to love?
On stage, dressed in black leggings (AI must have gotten a deal on those, too. A BOGO special? Buy one pair of JEANS, get some black leggings free?), a red dress, and heels, she played the piano and started slowly on Midnight Train To Georgia. Good job. Yes, I was holding my breath hoping she would not mess up (by her own admittance, she has not really played in years), and I was really happy when the music picked up and she got up from the piano to finish the song.
It was another solid job - she just IS. And I love her.
Randy called it "another great performance"; Ellen said, "you're never not good"; Kara said she "can't wait to see what you do next"; Simon called the song choice "sensational," said the vocals had "incredible moments," but that he could tell she was "over thinking" on the piano and cautioned her to "not let this process suck the identity out of you."
Simon, a fleet of Rotor Rooter trucks could not suck the identity out of Crystal.
Winding things up was young Aaron to sing Ain't No Sunshine. Usher called him "incredible" and tried to explain to him how that string of "I know"s in the song needed to be sung. I don't think he got it.
On stage he wore JEANS, a plaid shirt, and a leather hoodie and I will admit, while not being a member of Team Aaron, I am starting to like him a bit more each week. He sounded strong (cold must be gone), but NO, he did not "get" Usher's instructions on "I know." If it had been a record, I would have thought the needle was skipping.
Randy said it "started a little rough" and said it was just "kinda a-ight"; Ellen said, "good song choice ... good job"; Kara offered, "I liked it, I didn't love it."; Simon likened it to a "cupcake" next to Lee's "main course."
And that's it for R&B night. Did you like Usher as mentor? Do you think he helped a few lost singers find their way back? Do you think he's just one hot pile of manness? And are you ready to watch not only Usher, but Diddy, and Justin Bieber perform Wednesday night?
Is that YEAH I'm hearing? (Well, maybe not about the Bieber part...)
Recent Comments