The girls' performances were surely sponsored by Lunesta. Across the board, people agree that the first LIVE night of Idol Season 9 was not exactly a barn burner. A carbon monoxide leak? Maybe. I sure felt sleepy. But are our expectations too high, perhaps?
I think not.
After all, we have heard repeatedly from the judges how this year's group is so very talented, so very varied, so very fabultastic. So why did Girls' Night leave everyone so very, very drowsy?
Nerves? Of course, and who could fault them for faltering in their first true foray in front of the unwashed masses? Poor song choices? Always. That's inevitable. But come on, when you are given access to the entire Billboard Chart history (well, at least the songs cleared by AI), picking the homerun song isn't quite likely.
But therein lies the beauty of the show. If we didn't get to watch these kids mature, make better song choices, and ditch the questionable head regalia girls always seem to favor in the early eps, would we really stick around for five long months? Of course not. Not even the promise of Barry Gibbs's nipples or Meatloaf's sweaty carcass pushing up on a finalist is enough to keep us watching if we don't care about the kids.
That being said ... here's hoping the boys can bring some much needed "oomph" (God help me, I'm quoting Randy) to the proceedings...
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
With the guys in a police line-up, Ryan walked past, "Last night the ladies took the stage (and turned it into a slumber party), and tonight it's your turn to separate the men from the boys (Turn your head and cough?)..."
Loved his deliberate stop in front of Beaver Cleaver.
THIS. IS. AMERICAN ... Simon, stop talking. (Can these two ever just get on with things without put downs, double entendres, and gratuitous I-have-the-mic-now-bitchisms?)
The guys were intro'd and flowed down the stairs like a testosterone waterfall: Todrick Hall, Aaron Cleaver, Jermaine Sellers, Tim Urban, Joe Muoz, Tyler Grady, Lee DeWyze, John Park, Big Mike's Big Mouth, Alex Lambert, Casey James, and Andrew Garcia.
A quick howdy-do to the judges - Ellen wearing Simon's black sweater from Tuesday night, Randy Huxtable working a cardigan from Cliff's closet, Kara I'm-A-Hell's-Angel-On-The-Weekend DioGuardi in chains, studs, and rivets, and Rico Suave' Cowell, casual in a white dress shirt unbuttoned to reveal his forest of chest foliage.
Talking about last night, and advice for the guys, Randy noted their "interesting diversity"; Kara cautioned them to watch out for "nerves" and to basically go to their happy place (kind of dangerous advice for a guy, Kara); Ellen talked about how surprised she was to realize it is "totally different here than at home. If we're saying you don't sound good, you sound worse at home."; Simon was as blunt as a spoon, "If you lose it tonight or forget the words, your career is over."
Oh come on, Simon. Lose that threat. This year's Hollywood Round put paid to that. How many of those guys on stage totally brain farted their lyrics - even in the final performances - yet still made it through?
Up first, Todrick Hall, our 24 year old writer, actor, dancer. Nice kid, you like him right away. He took the stage dressed in JEANS, a gray shirt, biker boots, a ref whistle, and a black leather jacket on which he had installed a solar panel - is that a tax write-off like insulated windows?
Ryan announced he would be singing Kelly Clarkson's Since U Been Gone, but what he sang was truly unrecognizable.
At first, I kind of liked it. After all, they constantly hear "make it your own" and "take a risk." Well, what could be riskier than to take a hit from the first American Idol and flip it around so completely that it held your interest, turning you into an aural gold miner, panning for the original nuggets?
I actually kind of liked the twists and turns until he hit the chorus. If there were nuggets here, they were pyrite, not gold.
Ellen said the "chorus was a little rough, the singing wasn't the greatest, but you're such a great performer"; Randy called him "mad talented" but cautioned him to never "completely obliterate a song"; Kara echoed Randy's comments, but acknowledged Todrick "took a risk"; Simon, always ready to Hannibal Lector a kid's dreams, cut to the heart of the matter, "You came over as a dancer trying to sing, rather than a singer who can dance ... you completely murdered the original song ... verging on stupid."
But how do you really feel, Simon?
As Ryan discussed the comments with Todrick, the camera did a quick cut to Beaver who was wetting himself up in the balcony...
Young Cleaver was next - Aaron Kelly, the person who received the cute, nonthreatening teen boy baton handed off by David Archuleta. His Cleaverness aside, I think he looks like the lovechild of Matthew Modine and David Faustino from Married With Children.
Despite a serious fulb of his lyrics to Angel during his final H Week performance, Aaron fills a much needed demographic pie slice, so here he is. Dressed for an outing with friends for some Skeeball at Dave & Buster's - Aaron wore JEANS an untucked plaid shirt rolled up to the elbow, and an entire tube of hair gel.
Singing Here Comes Goodbye, I admit the kid has talent, but I also admit to snickering a tad because the song's lyrics are so far beyond his current range of life experience. No worries for him though, the tweens will happily be burning out the number 2 on their cell phones for him.
Simon called it "quite a good performance" but told him he needs to work on the "self belief, confidence"; Kara told him, "You have no idea how great your raw talent is. You'll get better every week."; Randy complimented his "huge voice"; and Ellen assured him that he's going to be there " a long time."
Note: Finger origami is not just lame, it's double lame when guys do it. Please stop.
Jermaine Sellers is at the top end of the age spectrum at 27. But he's not too old to learn a lesson. His video package included his final performance of Man In The Mirror and his admonishing the band for messing up the end. He took advantage of his interview to admit that, while he felt like "Boo Boo The Fool" when they messed it up, he would never throw anyone under the bus again.
Taking the stage to sing Get Here, he was dressed in JEANS (I swear Idol should come out with their own line), a black shirt, biker boots, a black silk flower on his lapel, and a top coat with tails. Oh, and he is Season 9's resident Chapeau Chap.
He is obviously comfortable on stage, and has an interesting range to work with, but if you rewind and look away? Dude sounds like a lady. Seriously.
Ellen is a "huge fan" but felt he was "pushing a little too much ... trying too hard"; Randy started with an ominous, "YO." Then he reiterated the "trying to do too much vocally" refrain; Kara told him to make his runs meaningful. (Like ecoli, Jermaine, not like a bad burrito from Taco Bueno); Simon said it "sounded so over the top" he may very well have "totally blown" his opportunity.
Ellen chimed in after Simon (she has done this consistently - softening his harsher critiques) with, "I think people will vote for you."
This was followed by Ryan asking Jermaine if he had made up with Michael after the whole band-bus debacle. Jermaine: "Michael who?"
Now, it was not a slight to the show's music guru who came up on stage - Jermaine was seriously perplexed because he had sung MJ's song during that whole bus crash.
Hugs were exchanged, let's move on.
Up in the Red Room, Ryan pimped the most stupid contest in the world, the Design-a-Coke-Cup Challenge. If you give two poops in a whirlwind, head over to AmericanIdol.com for details.
Tim Urban was up next - Tim's the guy who didn't make it into the Top 24, but through a poor turn of events for one guy who did, he received a magic phone call from producer Ken Warwick tellings him he was back in. (Ken is slowly regaining the hearing in his left ear from that phone call.)
On stage, he walked out in JEANS (ok, seriously - tonight's episode brought to you by DENIM: The Fabric Of Our Contestants' Lives), a zipper laden Member's Only jacket, and a helmet made of hair.
On the record right now: I HATE, DESPISE, ABHOR, WANT-TO-SHAVE every head coiffed this way. It looks like a hair condom.
Trojan Tim chose One Republic's Apologize, and boy, does he have a lot to be sorry for. Uncomfortable on stage, cat rebellion inducing falsetto, it was all so very bad.
Simon congratulated him for coming back, but then said that "based on that performance, we made the right choice the first time around." He called him "weak ... not a natural performer ... your voice isn't good enough."
Kara said the "music overpowered" him; Randy brought it to his attention (why someone didn't during rehearsals is beyond me) that he doesn't have a falsetto; Ellen was left with, "with the sound down, you're adorable."
OK, so he gets the deaf community vote? I don't think so. Cute doesn't cut it at this stage of the game.
Up next was Joe Munoz, 20, a student, and someone who has had precious little face time this season. Unfortunate because the kid can sing.
Choosing You and I Both by Jason Mraz, he sat on a stool in JEANS, a black jacket, and a metallic pashmina?!?
OK, neckery aside, I like his voice - it's smooth, clear, effortless. Plus he was enjoying himself so much that I found myself smiling in return.
Ellen said he was "so right there" and "really, really good"; Randy said the song choice was "not quite, for me for you, but you worked it out"; Kara said there were a few "issues" but that he was "so far, the best"; Simon lectured Joe about the power of Idol in being able to make worldwide stars, and then informed him that he wasn't one of them, calling his performance, "ok, safe, forgettable ... rather limp ... like our host."
OK, someone get the vat of Jell-o and just let them wrestle this thing out.
Moving on to Tyler Grady, he of the rectangular jaw and Leif Garrett hairdo...
Tyler chose to sing the 70's anthem American Woman dressed in black leather pants, a blue button up shirt, with cufflinks, no less, and a sad looking blue scarf as a tie (seriously, that thing was so shriveled it needed Viagra). After a slow intro, the band picked up, and he busted out his best Val Kilmer-as-Jim Morrison moves. Sorry, but this kid is more about the show than the vocals. He's not a bad singer, but man, is he distracting.
Simon said it looked like he went to "Pretend To Be A Rockstar School"; Kara asked him to "do something more than the schtick"; Randy said it was "style over substance, and if anyone knows about that, it's Mr. Substanceless Style himself; Ellen said he was good at "copying the poses" but was "lacking the charisma."
All that being said, I think he could get better and provide much needed Summer Tour energy.
Lee Dewyze, 23, separated at birth from Elliott Yamin was next in the Cheerio.
He chose one of my favorite songs, Chasing Cars by Snow Patrol. On stage with his guitar, some JEANS, and a t-shirt emblazoned with "My Weapon of Choice" (although the guitar hid what that weapon was), he took the song, twisted it a tad, but stayed true to the original. He was a little shaky in spots, but overall, I like the guy's raspy quality.
Ellen called it a "really good song choice" and lauded his "distinctive sound"; Randy said "it didn't quite work" because Lee is "more of a rocker" (Randy, stop calling Ellen, "E" - she gives you that look every time you do it - sooner or later she's going to bludgeon you to death with one of your oversized wristwatches.); Kara told him to "attack" things with more "soul, blues, rock"; Simon disagreed and said, "I thought this was the best performance. This guy is a naturally good singer."
John Park is a mystery to me - obviously he can sing, but he has received so little coverage, he has practically been tattooed with the word CHAFF across his forehead. Good thing his hair helmet covers it...
I do remember John was the one Shania went all double entendre about - "bottom end" and all. For that, he is willing to marry her.
John chose God Bless The Child, and he looked good on stage in JEANS, a gray T, a black blazer, and boat shoes (ahhhh, I love it when the 80s come back to haunt the fashion world). The kid has a really nice voice, but it was an odd choice - maybe if Idol adds a Gospel theme night, but for his first outing? I honestly could not decipher half the lyrics he warbled and was happy when it was over.
Simon called it "very flat, zero emotion ... kind of a pointless performance"; Kara said there was "no connection, it was a bit sleepy"; Randy said it made John come across as "old, out of sorts"; and Ellen said his song choice was "not one that gets the young girls to vote" although she, personally, liked the performance.
Then it was Big Mike's turn. Of course we got to relive the moment we have relived at least five times since we originally lived it - the phone birth of his daughter. One last "Ahhhhhh" and can we move forward? OK.
On stage in a bolt of plaid fabric stretched across his wingspan - that child is ripped - playing his guitar (yes, wearing JEANS from Del Griffith's favorite store, Chalmer's Big and Tall - extra points if you get the reference and can name the movie), Mike sang This Love.
OK, I can't help it. The guy is not Pavarotti by any means, but I like him. He makes me smile. Yes, it's personality over pipes, but personality does count for something.
Ellen echoed the voices in my head with "so much personality"; Randy said Mike "brought the energy up"; Kara said that while he is not "outrageously great" he is comfortable with himself; Simon likened him to the "support act before the main act."
I don't think he's in any trouble for a few weeks to come. Plus, if we're lucky, we may get to see that phone birth again ... and again ... and again...
Alex Lambert, 19, is a high school student from Texas who also favors that smashed to the head hairstyle. Points to him for dissing, and rightfully so, Mary Powers for her heinous behavior towards him during Group Round. Comfy watching the show from home, Mary?
Alex chose to sing Wonderful World - dressed in a beige jacket, JEANS, and dimples - though his cuteness could not overcome his total deer-in-the-headlights performance. He stared into the camera with a look that said "I am one sneeze away from adding a Goodyear sized skidmark to my underwear."
Oh it was bad. And that one line he repeated several times? "Here with me ... ... ... ... ... ee?"
Simon said "that was the most uncomfortable performance of the night"; Kara said "he needs a hug"; Randy told him to "do it with conviction" (that's right, Andrew. If you're going to lay down a skidmark, don't think bacon, think hamhock!); Ellen complimented him for "holding onto the mullet" and then compared him to "an unripe banana."
He still has a peel? Get it? Appeal? Ahem...
Finally, tonight's dessert course, Casey James, our 27 year old musician from Texas. In his video he admitted to being a little embarrassed by all the Kara attention.
So what happens?
The poor kid has to struggle through his entire song while Kara and Co. play immature, distracting games.
He looked good (duh) in JEANS (double duh), a white, untucked shirt with black embroidery, and a headful of Pantene products while he played his guitar and sang Heaven. But from the very first note, when the audience started laughing at Kara's arms being waved by Randy, he had to struggle to stay focused. Look, the guy isn't being voted off this, or any, island anytime soon, but still - is it too much to ask the judges to keep it together and show a tad of respect?
Kara started with "I don't recognize you with your shirt on."; Ellen added, "I could feel Kara undressing you with her eyes" but said he was "going to get votes like crazy"; Randy said, "great song choice"; Kara piped back up with "You are eye candy, but you are also ear candy."; Simon offered, "We were both cursed with good looks." He liked that Casey's stage presence is "very honest, very sincere .. obviously the cougar likes you..."
And Casey looked like he wanted the floor to open up and swallow him.
Bringing up the rear, the much anticipated performance by Andrew Garcia. Unfortunately, he tried to top what he did with his acoustic version of Straight Up during Hollywood Week by giving Fall Out Boy's Sugar, We're Going Down Swinging the same treatment.
It didn't work.
Sugar is meant to be a big, raucous song - not a stripped down, unplugged dirge. Andrew: great voice, totally wrong song.
Simon called it "too serious, too undulgent, a bit forgettable"; Kara said that while he is "great" it was a "strange rendition of the song"; Randy just added, "I'm a fan of you."; and Ellen encouraged him with, "I think you're going to stick around."
I do, too. He's good, not egomaniacal, and he had the pimp spot of the evening. He's far from in danger.
So, let's hear it for the boys. Maybe a little more pulse than the girls? Who are your early favorites? Anyone else feel for Casey? (Down people. I said FEEL FOR CASEY. Not anyone else want to feel Casey?)
Recent Comments