Ahh, Omaha. St. Louis may have the Gateway Arch, but it is Omaha which goes by the moniker: "Gateway To The West".
My question is this: Will the talent found there be a gateway to aural bliss or to the seventh circle of Hell?
It’s well known that you can get a great steak in this town, and when it comes to high tech – Newsweek once put it on the Top Ten lists of electronic havens – but come on. Compared to the glittery coasts and well known bustling metroplexes of this country, Omaha doesn’t exactly spring to mind when you think musical talent. Nashville, LA, New York, of course ... but Omaha? Not quite.
Right?
Well, to those who echoed "Right" (including me before investigating), Omaha actually has a longstanding relationship with the artistic community. The largest urban artists' colony in the world, the Bemis Center for Contemporary Arts, was founded in Omaha in 1981, nurturing performers of all ilk. And the annual Omaha Blues, Jazz, & Gospel Festival celebrates local music along with the Omaha Black Music Hall of Fame.
So is there hope that deep in the heart of this country, far away from the bright lights of Broadway, the flashing bulbs of a paparazzi strewn LA, there might be hiding the next American Idol?
That remains to be seen. Surely we’ll see more auditioners allowed through to the judges simply because they have a good "ridicule factor" – think Angel Pimp. Paula Caulker, er Stalker, the lardish guy who got waxed to be more appealing in his Princess Leia get-up – and probably a few more who have actual industry experience, but who have failed in the past to achieve superstardom.
Look familiar? (Surely you recognize him.) That’s Carla My-VISA-got-me-disqualified Hennessey, who I mentioned last week has had her shot at recording fame via MCA Records.
And according to insiders, the top 24 (who will be revealed next week) include a preponderance of individuals who have already either scored record deals (Maverick Records, J Records, Arista Nashville...one who was nominated for a Grammy for a duet with Alicia Keys smartly dropped out) won televised contests (Star Search, Monique’s Fat Chance, Nashville Star...), or have been on the inside of the industry, only to fail and find themselves back on the outside of the industry.
I honestly do not have a problem with truly talented folks auditioning for this show – the whole idea is to be entertained and launch someone with raw talent into the music stratosphere. But when so many of the finalists come with prior grooming, experience, and savvy – is it really a fair fight for the prize?
Perhaps the producers have loaded the show so as to avoid another Sanjaya debacle? Seriously, we were all entertained, until we all became scared to death he may actually win the damned thing. And I still wake up screaming at night over Kevin Covais and his eerie resemblance to that brainy chicken in the cartoons.
I guess I just fall into the camp of Let’s-Keep-It-Real. Don’t give me regurgitated music industry talent, when I know perfectly well that somewhere in this big country there is another Kelly Clarkson, Clay Aiken, or Carrie Underwood waiting to be discovered and transformed in front of our eyes each week.
That transformation, that finding themselves, that increased confidence which grows week by week is the true key to why we watch this show. It’s a process. One we like to think is in our control.
I’m afraid the producers may have already shot themselves in the foot this season. Or at the very least, have loaded a bullet into the American Idol revolver and are playing a game of Russian Roulette with how this show is received from here on out.
But let’s get to the recap and see just what new ringers – er – contestants advance to Hollywood from Omaha. (And if you’re interested in reading more backstory on many of the possible finalists, CHECK IT OUT.)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
OK, one thing before I get started. My daughters thought you may be interested to know what this recapping process looks like (Please God, tell me you have more interesting things in your life that that...), so here is a picture they took of me tonight.
Thrilling, isn't it?
Recapping involves comfy clothes, a rearranging of my favorite chair, the remote in one hand, a smooth writing pen in the other, and a notebook in my lap. Feel free to now Oooo and Ahhhhh.
Moving on...
Ryan opens the show by talking about the past seven years worth of auditions taking place in the "biggest and busiest cities" - New York, Chicago, Las Vegas, LA...
I suppose this was supposed to be a tactful way of saying, "But tonight, we come to Butt F*ck, in the heartland of these United States."
But to quote Little Miss Sunshine from last week, "Whatev."
Another 10,000+ folks turned out in Omaha, including a rather zaftig young lady (now, I’m being tactful) who sauntered in wearing an "I Beat Anorexia" t-shirt. I laughed. Sue me. No, I don’t think anorexia is funny. I just appreciate a good sight gag. And she certainly gagged my sight. Seriously, I think some dinner dribbled out my tear ducts.
Simon and Randy arrive – Paula’s plane has been delayed – so the proceedings get underway with the two of them. But not before Simon compliments Randy on his latest frames – bright purple – obviously from Prince’s Purple Rain Collection.
First in is Chris Bernheisal, 25, and boy howdy!, he is excited to be here, telling the cameras, "I am so happy, I feel like I could explode and happiness will go flying everywhere."
(Insert muffled sound of my filthy, giggling, gutterbound mind as I think, "Hmmm, I hate it when happiness gets on the sheets...in my hair"...ok, I’ll stop...)
"This is the greatest moment of my life."
At this point, Kendall spoke up, "He’s going to suck, I just know it."
Yes, I agree – get that hind tit ready, please.
Walking into the audition room, Chris has come bearing gifts for the judges – a stuffed dog for the Dawg (how original), a sweatshirt for Simon (because he wears them SO often), and a stuffed cat for Paula (a cat which takes an immediate flying leap courtesy of Simon). Chris also has a mini photo album containing nothing but shots of him and Kelly Clarkson. (I wonder if he exploded happiness all over her?)
Bribery over, he tells them he is there to audition because American Idol is "about giving people a second chance at their dream." (Yes, the final 24 would appear to be bearing out that second chance theory...).
He then choked up because he’s been "waiting for this my whole life."
You’re 25, kid, the show has been on for six years – do the math. I think the product equals SAD.
Breaking two of the larger commandments, If thou hast testicles, thou shalt not singeth a song originally sungeth by someone witheth ovaries, and Thou shalt not singeth a song made incredibly famouseth by another Idol unlesseth thou can singeth the pants off saideth Idol..
He launched into Kelly’s Since U Been Gone, and Kendall could only manage to speak in IM – "OMG" – that’s how bad it was.
It was so bad, so flat, crepes were offended.
And then, he suddenly flung himself at the floor and attempted a handstand while still singing.
I joined Kendall in her IMspeak, adding "WTF?!?" Seriously, you’ve got to be kidding me.
Thankfully, Simon interrupted him, told him, "I like you, love the bribes, but the singing wasn’t good enough."
Oh, ok. Dreams crushed, life shattered, happiness backing up and turning blue. What does he do? Cry? Rant? Beg? Plead?
Um, no. He "auditions" to do the Red Carpet for the finale. And Simon tells him to tell the local Fox affiliate he said YES.
Chris then exploded – happiness drenching everyone in the room. He continued to ejaculate his bliss in the confessional – in fact, it wasn’t a melt down, it was a melt up - he was the happiest reject I have ever seen in seven seasons.
Next up, Jason Rich (careful not to slip in the residual happiness there, Jason), 21, a part-time farmer from Stout, Iowa, population 500. Jason is a good looking kid in a laid back, humble, five o’clock shadow kind of way.
Choosing to sing When You Say Nothing At All (one of my favorite songs off the Knotting Hill soundtrack), he manages to get out the first line, and then ... silence.
Nerves. You can practically hear his blood rushing through his veins and his inner monologue screaming "WTF are the words, you idiot?!?"
He restarted, nailing the first line, and then ... black out.
Deep breath. (Inner monologue: "You big hillbilly cootie, WTF are the words?!?")
He started again, this time managing to make it through the first line, and most of the second before his mental John Deere tipped.over.
Refusing to give in to nerves the size of hay bales, he launched into it again, and somehow managed to keep things on course. And even though he sounded a bit screamchy in parts, he actually has a great voice. He just has a greater case of performance anxiety (he should talk to Chris about curing that)
Randy and Simon both gave him Yeses, but Simon warned him that he would never get a second chance like that again. Either come ready to explode happiness, or keep your vocal impotence at home.
After a break, Paula finally arrived in a casual aqua tunic which matched perfectly the large golden seahorse strung around her neck. You snazzy little sea monkey, you.
I have to ask, was anyone else a little skeeved out by Simon saying, "Paula, come to Simey." when she walked into the room? Oh wait – never mind – I forgot the general consensus was that we are all still waiting our turn for the Simon-goes-down-hard-on-everyone ride.
What followed next was Twinkie filling of the fluffiest order – a crapapalooza called You Forgot The Lyrics! – misfits all, culminating in a cowboy who had OD’d on Prozac. I don’t so much think he had forgotten the lyrics, as he was ready to fall asleep.
Moving on...
Rachael Wicker is a pretty girl, in a buff, don’t-eff-with-me kind of way. And she goes around the holding room challenging all comers to arm wrestling bouts – she has won six championships, you know. She finally takes on Ryan, who I think only agreed so as to show off his big, manly bicep on national TV. Nice, Ryan – we know you work out.
In the audition room, she asks to wrestle Simon, but he declines. Simon obviously works out too, but Simon also has the wisdom to not go near a possible female smackdown in front of the cameras. That just wouldn’t do.
Rachael settles for singing Don’t Tell Me To Stop Loving You, and it turns out her vocal cords are as strong as her arm muscles. She had gorgeous control as she rode the note elevator up and down. I was impressed (and NO, not because she could kick my ass).
Simon actually gave her a No, but he was overthrown by two Yeses from Randy and Paula. Paula, all 100 pounds of her (yes, I know, I should talk) then tried to arm wrestle Rachael, who just about put Paula through the top of the glass table.
Another break and we come back to a shot of a young man who has apparently just sat down on a railroad spike outside the convention center. He is flailing about, thrashing at his guitar, and screaming, "Wooow, ow, ow, ow ,owwwww. Wow, ow, ow, ow, owwwww, Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!" (and not in a good-happiness spewing way)
Well, apparently we have not had enough brazen lady buffness, so we are now treated to Sarah Whitaker, a former professional wrestler who went by the name Lady Morgue. And yes, if you were not watching, I assure you her name fit her appearance.
I’m sorry, but Sara, Lady Morgue, whatever the hell you want to call yourself – you personified the word "fugly". Seriously, you brought it to life, beat it to death, and then skinned it and wore its hide.
Dressed all goth, black head to toe, with a slight bus stop at her cranberry wrapped belly, she had scraggly black hair, and eyebrows the shape of Boomerangs which only served to highlight how Fastey (Pasty Face) she was.
I don’t have Clue One what she attempted to sing, but Simon summed it all up with "You’re just really strange, Sarah."
So it was No from him, No from Randy, and it sounded like Paula squeaked Yes – hard to tell – she was facedown on the table.
Sarah exited, then Ryan stuck his head in to cause trouble. Poor Sarah wasn’t thrilled. Well, neither was I, Ryan, and I would like to know who to see to get those two minutes of my life back.
At Simon’s urging, Smarty Pants Seacrest swaps places with Paula, taking her place behind the table and pondering, "How do I pretend to be overpaid for doing no work."
It’s ok, Ryan. I have every confidence you are well schooled in this area.
Walking into the middle of this round of Dysfunctional Family Feud is Samantha Sidley, 22, who nervously began singing I Don’t Know Why.
She sounded smooth, velvety, albeit in a totally Norah Jones mimic kind of way, but she definitely had control over her vocals.
Of course, Ryan aka Judge Extraordinaire (sorry, but he chaps my ass like a flame three feet high), tells her to work on her self confidence, at which point Paula bursts in and kicks his whiney caboose to the curb.
Paula thinks she can sing just fine, tells her to work on her showmanship, and gives her a Yes which is echoed by Simon and Randy.
Poor Samantha – she should have been excited, but she just seemed completely confused by their antics and wanted out of there.
She took her Golden Ticket and ran.
But her win seemed to turn on the golden faucet as Elizabeth Erkert sang Heard It Through The Grapevine (I was not about to lose my mind, but she did sound fine) and took her ticket home, despite Simon’s misgivings about her performance.
She will be followed to Hollywood by Denise Jackson who sang One Night Only from Dreamgirls; and Michael Sanfilippo who won his ticket on the power of the Stevie Wonder tune, If You Really Love Me. (That remains to be seen Michael – I didn’t see enough of you to decide.)
The cameras then cut to one of the few funny moments of the evening as Elizabeth made her way down the escalator telling everyone, "I can’t wait to get to Hollywood and prove Simon wrong, that I AM America’s next Top Model..."
(Insert sound of crickets chirping)
Actually, insert sound of hysterical laughter as she realized what she said. Hmmm, perhaps a new commandment is in the offing? Thou shalt know which damned reality show thou is auditioningeth for.
Another break and then it was time for the telenovela of the evening. Tonight it’s Angelica Puenta, 19, starring in "I Ran Away From Home Cause My Father Is An Asshat But I Still Love Him Cause He’s A Well Intentioned Asshat Plus My Story Will Get Me More Facetime On American Idol."
Long novela, short: Left home after continually head butting with father, issues with both parents, now lives with Grandma, but still misses overly strict Dad.
Dressed in a simple black top and gray skirt, she started to sing The Power of Love (Celine’s version) and while it wasn’t one to keep Ms. Dion up at night with worry, Angelica does have the power of vocal cords.
Randy and Simon gave her Yeses, but warned her to stop listening to records and work on discovering who SHE is, Paula warned her about her lack of performance skills, but also gave her a Yes.
Ryan, ever ready to intrude, called up Dad on the cell phone and all of America got to hear his pride as he told Angelica that her winning a golden ticket was "bad ass".
My God, that was a Hallmark moment if I ever saw one. Anyone have a Kleenex? Two if you have them – I just found another blop of happiness left over from Chris.
After another break, in which we see that House is again confronting THE. BIGGEST. CASE. OF. THE. SEASON! (Donna from The West Wing has red eyes! Visine, stat!), we return to salute Chris Daughtry, "one of Idol’s biggest success stories".
Look, if ever there was a case to be made for NOT winning this damned show, Chris is it. Much beloved, completely admired during his season, and kicked off way too early, he went on to record his music, his way, and can be heard around the clock across the radio dial. I love his album, it is on every iPod in our house.
But yes, like Bo Bice, he inspired a whole collection of wannabe Rockols (Rocker Idols) who show up each season now – long hair, soul patches, tattoos, tongue rings, ready to molest Matilda the Mikestand if they are just given the chance.
Tonight, it is David Cook, with his red bangs, faux hawk, requisite soul patch, and Blake Lewis argyle vest, who is ready to rock the Idol World.
He begins singing Bon Jovi’s Livin’ On A Prayer and I have to say, Go, David. He sounded great – not too gravelly – more like he had swallowed a handful of sand, not pebbles – and he had good control.
The judges all loved him so look for his red bangs and Cliff Huxtable wardrobe in Hollywood.
Of course, by giving us two good performances in a row, the producers must now make us suffer.
Enter Johnny Escamilla who admits he is "pretty much the weirdest guy you’ll ever meet."
Um, psst, Johnny – I don’t think anyone’s going to disagree with you on that one, what with you bogarting not only Liza Minelli's hairstyle, but her wardrobe, too.
That was some disco ball of a jacket, was it not?
He droned on that he couldn’t really think of a performer to compare himself to, but then hit on James Brown.
That thunderous noise coming from the earth’s crust is the sound of James spinning in his grave...
He enters the audition room and as he begins to talk to the judges, Paula lets out one huge, and hugely amplified, URP. Hiccups. Yes, Paula, drink some more Coke – I always find that carbonated beverages help when my tummy is already horking up air.
Johnny begins to sing Shout! and for a moment – just the first note, mind you – I actually thought the kid was going to sing well. That note was strong, in tune, powerful...
But then he began to sing the rest while flailing about like someone who had just had their genitals hooked up to a car battery on Moment of Truth. I’m not kidding. It looked like someone was tasing a Blues Brother.
No big surprise that Simon, Paula, and Randy declined his kind offer to come to Hollywood.
As they did with the collection of vocal rapists (seriously, my ears felt molested after this) who made up the montage of "Clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right – here you and I are, stuck in the middle with them"
I swear, they must just ask people who didn’t make it past the producers, "Hey, you suck, but are you willing to grab ankle for a chance to be on American Idol?"
After the horned Heippies (Heidis + Hippies), Tex who finally got some lyrics right, and a dude in a teal shower cap, bathrobe, and what looked like my Swiffer Duster, I had to echo the song: PLEE-EE-EE-EE-EEESE, STOP!
One last break brought us back to the final contestant of the day, Leo Marlowe who comes from, and I quote, "the smallest town in the history of life" – population 200.
He explained to the judges how his "Mom raised the perfect Homecoming queen, too bad it wasn’t one of her daughters" and I immediately loved him. He is funny, self deprecating, humble, not over-the-top.
Singing A Song For You, I was really surprised at the depth of his singing voice vs his speaking voice. He had excellent tone, control, an easy quality about it all.
Simon said he was "very good, very open" and "I like you."; Randy called him a "nice guy"; and Paula, obviously excited about her video debuting before the Superbowl, jumped up and exclaimed "Touchdown!"
So, in all, 19 people found their way out of the obscurity of Omaha and will be showing up to face down Baby, Baby, My Girl, and some yet-to-be-revealed Bee Gees song in Hollywood.
I personally thought Omaha yielded more ground round than it did top dollar Kobe beef, and that this episode fell seriously short.
I have never said this during auditions before, but I am completely bored. The good is predictable. The bad isn’t nearly bad enough. And it all seems, more than ever, handpicked by a very nervous group of producers.
One more city to go – Miami, Florida – I am holding out serious hope for an uptick in the freak factor. It’s what I love about Miami most – the collection of people with personalities as bright as the art deco buildings which line the beach.
Because right now, I can only echo what that girl leaving the auditions screeched – "Holy crap!"
And then some, honey.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Your thoughts? Are you as bored as I am? Are you just ready to get to Hollywood and get this group hacked down to 24? Are you bothered by the fact that so many of the finalists have prior industry experience? And most important, don’t I look cute in my comfy recapping clothes?
(Feel free to vomit now...)
Recent Comments