Another week, another chance to marvel at the unequalled glory that is American Idol. It is a thing of beauty, is it not?
Is it not??
Here we stand, almost halfway to the true finals, and in our midst still lurks – hell, lurks is not the word I’m looking for...hmmm...what is? Grandstands? Parades? Taunts? Paris Hiltons?
Paris Hiltons.
That one’s good. It sums up a person so full of their own hubris and so believing in their own press that they are truly convinced they can do no wrong, ergo, they constantly assault the public retina with their talent for having no talent, their seriously questionable fashion statements, and their roachlike ability to survive everything from Raidesque sprays of media pest repellent to nuclear tabloid blasts.
So – here we stand, almost halfway to the true finals, and in our midst still Paris Hiltons the unlikeliest of American Idols - Sanjaya Malakarma. Seriously, Ed, how much good stuff must this kid have floating around in the universe to keep seeing him through week after week? What did he do before coming on this show? Build an entire village in Africa, adopt ten Vietnamese children, go vegetarian – hell, fruititarian? – give a couple gallons to the Red Cross, kiss the Pope’s ring, send Pamela Anderson posters to the troops in Iraq, turn in that dollar bill he found on the floor at school, and smack Don Imus on behalf of the girls’ basketball team at Rutgers?
I’m a firm believer in karma, both good and bad. So what has he done to be reaping such a windfall of "Special K", and while I’m asking questions, what in the hell did we do to be on the receiving end of such a pile of festering cosmic poo?
Well, I know what I did. I just got back from Vegas. But what about you? Did you kick your dog? Not tip your waiter? Did you cross the street without looking both ways? And YOU – I know about YOU – YOU removed the tag from your mattress, didn’t you? That’s it. That’s what knocked the Earth off its axis and set this whole Sanjayapalooza in motion.
Whatever the reason – S&M is definitely upsetting the season. Viewership is actually down – not by much, but enough for it to make the news.
According to Newsweek, "through last Tuesday, an average of 28.8 million young adults watched the show this season, down 4 percent from the year earlier."
Don’t worry, AI will still retain its title as the most watched television show since the invention of the boob tube, but something telling is happening this season. And one need only surf the web a tad to discover the unrest, disgust, and growing disinterest.
Much of the attention has been directed Sanji’s way – he is hanging around like toilet paper stuck to a shoe with bubble gum, while stronger vocalists are shown the door. This, in itself, is a major insult to the hardcore, dyed-in-the-wool AI viewer. But dig a tad deeper and you’ll discover the other reason:
People are just plain bored, on the whole, with the contestant pool this season.
Sure, we can all agree that Melinda Doolittle should just be handed the crown and then we can get on with our lives. Her perfection has even begun to be a tad snore-inducing. Perfection – boring? Say it ain’t so! And we can all tell that Jordin Sparks has the most marketable presence and pop talent in the bunch. And yes, Blake (teeny, baby sized mouth opening aside) is adorable – in an I-really-get-hot-watching-guys-moonwalk-in-my-grandpa’s-plaid-pants kind of way.
But the rest? Will you really buy Phil Stacy’s CD? (Tip for him: they are holding open casting calls in Vegas next week for new Blue Man Group members!) What about Chris Richardson? I’d rather buy the original JT, thankyouverymuch. And Halitosis Scarnato? She leaves a bad taste in my eyes.
Simon has stated he will quit if Sanjaya wins this season. Now, while I still don’t think that’s a danger, he seems to be a big enough juggernaut of voting power (both those voting for him, and those who are against him voting for him), to jeopardize the advancement of Lakisha, Jordin, and definitely Blake.
The kid’s name is a household word. "Sanjaya" has been turned into a noun: You twit, you are such a Sanjaya! – a verb – Dude, you Sanjaya-ed my chance with Stacy! What were you thinking? – an adjective: My hair is SO Sanjaya-y today. I cannot get it to lay down – an exclamation: Holy Sanjaya, Batman!
He’s become such a pop culture icon that Kentucky Fried Chicken has jumped on his bandwagon. In an open letter to Sanny they offer him not only a lifetime supply of their famous cram-all-our-leftover-crap-in-a plastic-bowl Bowls, but also $5000 (whoa – deep pockets there, KFC), and a spot in an upcoming commercial (he’ll have plenty of experience what with all these Velveeta heavy Ford vommercials). All he has to do is wear his hair in a bowl haircut during an upcoming performance.
How "original". I would hope he would pass on the offer – not because he’s chicken (I know – that’s SO bad), but because when it comes to stupid, well, that idea is just extra crispy..
The point is, everyone knows who he is and is chomping at the bit to make him their star. So while Antonella Barba may have slid off the scandal radar when she was voted off, don’t look for Sanjaya to be leaving your TV sets anytime soon.
Personally, I think the perfect endorsement deal would be for Malka Seltzer. We can all drink it while we watch him sing. Plop, plop, fizz, fizz...
Now, onto the recap...
~~~~~~~~
Backstage with Lakisha’s cleavage ... oh, and the other contestants were there somewhere too ... Ryan asks, "How’s the energy?" to which Blake responded, "Owwwwwwww!!!"
I guess that means he either checked the energy by sticking his finger in a light socket, or that he’s just really excited. He’s also wearing yet another unforgivable hat on his head.
But no matter, because THIS. IS. AMERICAN. IDOL. Which means WE. CAN. WEAR. ALL. THE. STUPID. HATS. THE. BUDGET. WILL . ALLOW!
As the doors parted, kudos to Ryan for once again avoiding dandelion head by ducking the bright lights. He looked positively dapper in his dark suit, crisp white dress shirt and tie. His head exploding into flames would have detracted from the GQness of his look.
A quick howdy-do to the judges – Randy, who has once again stolen Lisa Loeb’s glasses; Paula, wearing a bolero and too much hairo in honor of tonight’s Latino theme; and Simon, hair freshly squared, in a blah gray shirt. I swear he’s as boring as a plate of refried beans.
As Ryan begins to intro Jennifer Lopez’s video footage, what’s this?!?! Hey, hey it’s a Monkee! Mickey Dolenz is in da house! Five extra points to anyone else out there who recognized him besides me.
But back to JLo, whom Ryan used words like "prolific" in describing. Um. Yeah. Look, I think she is beautiful, and I’m a closet lover of the Selena movie, but Jennifer Lopez is the Haley Scarnato of the music industry. Her voice is not hideous, but certainly not the strongest in the world. And one has to acknowledge that she owes much of her success to how little she has worn. Green Grammy dress, anyone?
That her current Spanish language album is #1 on the Billboard Latin charts does not surprise me. She had superior production skills and coaching through her husband, international superstar Marc Antony – I am a huge fan of his.
That being said, once she started talking, I did warm up to her more. She is a huge star, but she is also an admitted AI-aholic like the rest of us. Hi, my name is Jenny, and I love Sanjaya...
Her biggest words of wisdom to the kids who sat Kindergarten style on the floor around her feet? (Seriously, I thought she was going to start reading Green Huevos and Jamon.) "The key to Latin themed music: Passion."
Melinda drew the short straw tonight – not so much of a bad thing for someone as strong as she – and went first. Jennifer’s advice? Be "the sultriest, sexiest singer you ever saw."
I heard the alarm bells begin to ring. Melinda is neither. And one needs confidence in one’s self to properly sex across a stage in front of millions of people.
But she gave it her best shot. Coming down the ramp, Mel was dressed in a black asymmetrically cut dress, heels, Lakisha’s hand-me-down bling, and Diana Ross’s old hairstyle from The Supremes.
She looked mature. Not sexy. Melinda, Melinda, Melinda. What are we going to do with you?
My sister actually called after Mel sang – my sister who doesn’t watch the show, but who decided to tune in tonight to better "get" the recaps – and she was shocked when I told her Mel is only 27 years old. She said that if I had told her Melinda was 45, she would not have blinked.
So you see, everyone. It’s not just us.
But back to her performance. The black dress suited her, as it masked her body in all the right places, but regardless of how hard she tried to work it, she may as well have been phoning it in. The "moves" were stiff, the "sexiness" unnatural, uncomfortable. You could see behind her eyes that she was completely aware of herself tonight and it took away from her usual focus on the song.
Vocally, I cannot take a thing away from her, but overall, the performance was a snooze to me. Sway should be fun, sassy, seductive – it was none of those.
Randy said that while it was not her "best", it was "solid." Great, Randy. That sounds like you are critiquing a bowel movement. Paula, who happened to be wearing a silver sperm around her neck, called it "very, very sultry, very smooth"; Simon said, "It had to happen. I didn’t like it." Saying she "appeared much, much older" than she is, that it was "lounge-caberet", "lazy" and "a bit wooden", he truly relished finally being able to dress her down a bit.
But the thing is – it was warranted – although I wish he would stay out of my notes and stop reading over my shoulder. She is fabulous, but cannot afford to coast.
Next up was Lakisha sitting on the Chat Chairs with Ryan to answer the viewer question, "What made you try out for American Idol?" As anyone who keeps up with this show already knows, the answer is her 4 year old Bri, and the hopes for a better life for them both. Good answer, good answer... survey SAYS...
Jennifer’s advice for Kiki, who chose to sing Conga (pronounce it right, people – Coun – gah – that’s better) was to move with the rhythm. They practiced dance moves together and while JLo may look better doing them, Keeks certainly has the attitude to pull them off.
She started out on the bridge behind the judges, shaking her coun-gas full speed ahead. As my brother-in-law observed, "She had too much meat hanging out."
Dressed in a seriously, dangerously, darn near pornographically low cut red dress, which had accidentally been caught under someone’s tires, her hair was sleek and her lips painted to match the dress (red – not the tire tracks).
She worked the little stage then moved to the big one and that was a slight problem. From the front, the dress was daring and fit to a "T" (and A), but unfortunately, baby got back, and those rear camera angles caught it all hanging out of that dress. It was very unflattering. But for what it’s worth Kiki? Backfat is of the devil, and we are all possessed to some degree.
As the song moved on and she moved around, she sounded out of breath. Thankfully she decided to stay put and her voice immediately got stronger. She exuded attitude and strut, and while it certainly wasn’t the best she’s ever done, it was more exciting than Melinda’s Sway.
Randy thought it "was hot, baby"; Paula started out with a compliment, "You look lovely", which loosely translates to, "Marshamallows, cotton balls, bunny ears - you sucked - daisies, candy canes, jelly beans."; Simon agreed with Paula – that Lakisha might have been "having fun", but he wasn’t sure "how much everyone at home was having."
Is her kidding? I was having a ball taking bets on whether her left boob or her right was going to make a run for the border first!
AFTER. THE. BREAK
. Ryan informed us that Idol Gives Back is continuing to grow and will now take up forty nonstop hours. OK, maybe I’m exaggerating a tad, but the roster of acts keeps getting longer and I fear I shall have to lay in a case of Red Bull and an extra spiral or three to document it all. New additions? Rascal Flatts, Earth, Wind & Fire, and Il Divo (gosh, I wonder how they got them?)
Next up to sing for Jenny From The Block? Chris, with Smooth, the song which burned up the airwaves courtesy of Rob Thomas and Carlos Santana in 1999, staying at number 1 for twelve weeks.
Jenny’s advice? Take it up a step – keywise – don’t sing it so low.
Flanked by a bongo player and a guitarist, Chris was wearing a pixelated red tshirt, black pants, a black jacket, and an I’m-a-bad-ass pocket chain. Sorry Chris – leave the pocket jewelry to the Chris Daughtrys of the world.
He started singing and it was so bad, I actually had to hit the pause button to regroup. Too low, completely boring, whiny, nasally – I could just imagine Rob Thomas smashing his big screen with Carlos Santana’s guitar.
I don’t get what is up with all the praise from the judges. Chris sings through his nose, and I swear, he always looks like he is high when he performs. Open your eyes, dammit!
There was nothing about this performance to erase the twelve weeks the original spent at the top of the charts.
Randy is an idiot, however, and said it was "a really good performance" and "very cool"; Paula – no surprise here, after all, she is wearing a sperm – called it a "hot, hot performance" and that he is "sexy"; the best Simon could give it is that he "actually preferred it to the first two".
Look, I know he’s not going away anytime soon, but that doesn’t mean I have to like it.
Another break and we returned to Haley being coached by J Lo to "bite all the words" to Turn The Beat Around – one of the hardest songs to sing, but also the one someone invariably attempts during Latin night – think Diana DeGarmo, Amanda Avila, Carmen Rasmussen...- she decided they needed a beat to practice with so she called Blake in to beatbox for them. Oh, how he loved his chance to spit for JLo.
With the lights flashing, Haley galloped down the ramp like a zebra in hot pants. I swear, if she makes it through one more week, she will be performing with fans or feathers.
She started singing – I think – I could hardly hear her over the background singers. But then, vocals are not her strong suit. Her legs were really loud though.
And in honor of Latin night, she was Mystic Tanned, all bronzed up, and wearing an entire tube of red lipstick. She was still sporting Kat’s old weave, and earrings so big they continually tried to escape through her hair to freedom.
She came out onto the small stage, screamed a bit, shook her booty – yes, the girl has a great body – but the whole show-it-off strategy has become overly obvious. It’s time to reign the bad boys in, drop the hemlines a few inches and attempt something that doesn’t reek of Pretty Woman Gone Wild At Porky's.
Even Antonella Barba covered it up every now and then. But then again, I guess if Haley leaves the body to the imagination, that will free us all to concentrate on her underdeveloped vocals.
Randy called it what it was, "karaoke"; Paula could only muster, "you had fun up there"; Simon went ahead and vocalized what everyone has been thinking, "Very good tactic right now – wear the least amount of clothes possible." Harsh? Maybe. But again, we have ALL been thinking the same exact thing.
Phil got his chance to slobber over La Lopez – seriously, he was completely freaked out to sing in front of her – but in the end, he managed to give her "goosepimples" and "you can’t buy those."
No, but you can buy really ugly hats, and Phil was wearing another one tonight. This one, an off center newsboy cap.
Sitting on a stool at center stage, he began singing, "Oh Maria, Maria...take this hat off my heada..."
OK fine, I sang that last part.
His outfit consisted of the hat, a peach shirt, JEANS, and a distressed blazer with grommets from the HeDazzler Collection. No shiny crystals for real men like Phil. Me punch holes in clothes!
As always, Phil’s big notes were huge, and overall, I thought he sounded more committed to what he was singing than anyone else who had gone before him tonight. There was emotion (albeit Peter Brady-When-It’s-Time-To-Change emotion) and he seemed to feel the song.
Randy said he had "great upper range" but that he "didn’t quite connect with the passion"; Paula said "it was a really good vocal"; Simon said Phil is a "nice guy" and that he chose "a good song", but that there was "no originality, it was a bit lifeless, a bit flat."
Love how each week Phil manages to sneak in something about his wife or kids – this week: his daughter has a stuffed bovine she calls Simon Cow.
Plane ticket to see Daddy: $250
Stuffed cow: $12.50
Simon being publicly milked for laughs: PRICELESS
Coming back from another emptying of the sponsors udders, we find Jordin sharing the Small Talk Stools with Ryan, viewer question: If you were in charge of choosing next week’s theme, what would it be?"
Love her answer: 80’s music. Go Jordin. I’d give anything to see Sanjaya rock some Guns n Roses or Motley Crue...
Choosing to sing The Rhythm Is Gonna Get You, J Lo said Jordin reminded her of Michael Jackson (?).
Dressed in black pants and a tan jacket/top with a wide collar, her hair slicked back into a low ponytail, Jordin looked great and, as usual, sounded equally as fabulous, although when she got going I was momentarily afraid she was going to take one of her eyes out with those earrings..
She worked the stage, never faltered vocally, and had her big finish. Like Melinda, I cannot take anything away from her vocals, but I felt that she could have had a bit more fun with the song tonight. Still and all, I love Jordin Sparks, her megawatt smile, and her infectious attitude.
Randy said she had "the yo factor on blast"; Paula just babbled something about her being "so authentic", "so you"; Simon, however, expressed his disappointment in all the performances, saying there had been "nothing stunning" thusfar.
Pull your shorts out of your crack, Simon. You’ll feel much happier.
Blakebox was up next to rehearse I Need To Know for Jennifer. Dicey affair considering her husband sang that song. She stressed to Blake that "these songs have to mean something", that he "has to get into the passion of the song".
That was actually spot-on advice for young Blake because, as was evidenced in last week’s butchering of Mack The Knife, Blake tends to play around a lot, but totally misses the point of the song he is singing.
Coming down the ramp, he was sporting more floppy pants (did you know he doesn’t like JEANS and makes his own pants – yes, even those plaid nightmares), Garanimaled red shirt and matching tennis shoes, and another F***ing fedora on his head.
His singing sounded great, but he looked like he was fresh from running for condo president of Del Boca Vista in that hat and Sansabelts.
(I’ll wait for you to nail down that Seinfeld reference.)
Ready? OK – moving on...
Blake actually connected with the song tonight, infused it with the necessary emotion and yearning, even making "baby girl" sound horny, not hokey. I just wish that damned hat was not blocking half his face the whole time. Come on Blake. You’re not in the Rat Pack and even Frank Sinatra took the hat off to sing.
Randy called it a "hot performance"; Paula called it "very smart" and that it "captured the essence" of who Blake is; Simon simply called it the "best performance so far."
But wait – he hasn’t seen Sanjaya perform yet!
J Lo stated that Sanny, who chose to sing the Spanish language song, Besame Mucho, "really, really impressed me" and that "I love Sanjaya!"
Sitting on a stool, Sanjaya was dressed in Converse, JEANS, a splotched t-shirt, blazer, and Marc Antony’s facial fur. My daughter said it looked drawn on. Then she likened him to Captain Morgan without the hat. He actually looked more like the lovechild of Jack Sparrow and DeBarge. And the mother in me just wanted to wipe off the chocolate milk moustache.
Whatever it was, he looked horrid. The hair shimmering with Jeri-Curl, and the Jon Waters pencil stache completely detracted from what was actually a pretty decent vocal from Sanjy From The Block.
He sang the Spanish portion perfectly (from what I could tell – then again, I don’t speak Spanish), sounded smooth throughout, and aside from the smarmy eye love (I didn’t know eyeballs could lick until tonight), it was not half bad. And I dare say he picked up a new legion of Spanish speaking young prepubes by singing to them in their native tongue.
Randy called him "one of the smartest contestants I have ever met" and said "that was really good"; Paula said he had "good pitch", that it was "smooth" and "very, very nice."; Simon stated that while he "couldn’t understand a word of it" and that Sanjaya "sang it like a 14 year old", "I’m gonna hate myself for this ... it wasn’t horrible."
I’m not sure who was more surprised by the admission – Simon or Sanjaya. But I can tell you for sure who was most excited – that cockatoo who was hanging all over Sanjaya’s sister. Come on, dude. That ponyhawk is, like, so three weeks ago.
And so ends Latin Night here at the American Idol Hacienda. No real flavor, not much heat, and certainly lacking in passion. But that’s ok. J Lo will be on hand Wednesday night to sing a song from her new CD - completely in Spanish – and whether you understand the words or not, I guarantee you her spicy moves will arouse more than just passion in the male viewers across the land.
Can you say, caliente? Adios till then...
Recent Comments